Nova Scotia Hybrids Jonathan Wilson December 14, 2010 FCG, Wine Spotlight 25 Comments As I read online articles and tweets, I see people discussing their local Pinot Noir harvests or how amazing the Cabernet Sauvignon is looking this year and, quite frankly, I get jealous. Not jealous that someone has the job they do; rather, I get jealous because I find myself a fine-wine lover/appreciator/sommelier in a geographical area with mostly French‐American hybrids—an area where most Vitis vinifera won’t ripen properly so we have to look to other grapes. After working as a sommelier in one of Halifax’s oldest and best-known hotels, I’ve had plenty of experience speaking with tourists about Nova Scotia’s wines. As you may expect, they always want to sample the local fare. However, unless they too are from an area that grows hybrids, I am met with a very confused look when presenting the wines. I explain to them the grapes we grow—l’acadie blanc, marechal foch, leon millot—and describe the style of wine they make. On more than one occasion I’ve been met with, “Oh, just give me the Merlot.” I sure don’t want to get into the fact that I said millot, not merlot, and I hand over the wine. Often they enjoy it and I am met with a comment such as, “I thought it was too cold to grow grapes in Nova Scotia.”. Now, we don’t grow only hybrids in Nova Scotia; in fact there are more Vitis vinifera planted every day. I have tasted some mind-blowing Pinot Gris, Riesling and Chardonnay, as well as some very good reds such as Pinot Noir and Cabernet Franc. The best part is that the quality keeps getting better. Nova Scotian wines are receiving more acclaim than ever. L’Acadie Vineyards’ Prestige Brut is fresh off a gold medal win at the 2010 Canadian Wine Awards, and the recently released Benjamin Bridge Méthode Classique sparkling wines have been praised by many, including Tom Stevenson, one of the world’s foremost experts in sparkling wines who called them “seriously good with the rare twin-ability to show well when young and promise even more for the future.” This brings me to my point: do we, as a wine region just on the cusp of more attention in the wine world stick to the virtually unrecognized hybrids we can ripen in our sometimes-harsh climate, or do we push the envelope and try to produce the better-known, higher-regarded wines made from Vitis vinifera grapes? Such is the conundrum faced by Nova Scotia’s wineries and, in particular, the crop of young, talented winemakers like Jean-Benoit DesLauriers of Benjamin Bridge, Gina Haverstock of Gaspereau Vineyards and Ben Swetnam of Avondale Sky Winery, who have come here after working and studying in some of the best terroirs known to human kind. After working with Grenache in California, Riesling in Germany and Pinot Gris in Alsace and New Zealand, how can one switch to Lucie Kuhlmann and Leon Millot in Nova Scotia? I asked Simon Rafuse, winemaker at Blomidon Winery in Canning, Nova Scotia, what he thought about the whole debate. Rafuse has a Master of Science degree from the University of Kent, United Kingdom and a Master of Viticulture and Oenology from Montpellier SupAgro, France. His work experience includes time at Chateau de Lancyre (Languedoc-Roussillon, France), Domaine Zind-Humbrecht (Alsace, France) and most recently William Hill Winery (Central Otago, New Zealand). “In Nova Scotia, French-American hybrid varietals make up the vast majority of our grape production. Our climate doesn’t really allow us to rely solely on Vitis vinifera, as winterkill, frosts, cool summers and even hurricanes can reduce yields to the point of absurdity. However, they can, and should, play a part in a winery’s production. Because of our reasonably warm autumns (we have the ocean to thank for that), we get excellent phenolic development without a dramatic increase in sugars or a decrease in acidity. Basically, this means we can get great flavours from vinifera and still have that bracing acidity that makes our wines unique, whether for still wines or sparkling.” When I started to write this article it had an anti-hybrid theme. I just can’t go “gaga” over them, especially the reds. However, I decided to consider the broader context. Nova Scotia is not a wine-drinking region, historically. Our per capita wine consumption has been estimated by Statistics Canada at 9.8L/per person. Compare that to 54L/per person in France and 50L/per person in Italy and you can see what I mean. Wine is a relatively new thing for us. If you look at sales trends from the Nova Scotia Liquor Corporation over the last 20 years, you see that Nova Scotians prefer rye, rum and beer—all things that are generally sweet and fairly acidic. So, naturally, I can see why the local wineries want to use hybrids. Wines made from hybrids tend to be very acidic and, in order to combat that acid, they take advantage of residual sugar for balance. Someone just getting into wine—someone who formerly drank “rum and coke”—would likely enjoy a Marechal Foch or a Baco Noir. I believe things happen for a reason. My science background reminds me about natural selection. If we are in a land too cold to grow certain red grapes from vinifera species, then so be it. Would I love to be in a region that grows the world’s best Cabernet Sauvignon? Of course. However, the local wineries need to make a product to support both the growing industry and their respective businesses while we wait to see how our vinifera will do. Think of it like this: I can’t throw a Frisbee for the life of me, but it is my dream to throw one well enough to compete world wide. Do I work only on my Frisbee skills and hope I become very good in a short period of time and that it pays off immediately? No, that’s far too big a risk. Instead, I practice Frisbee while also writing. Now, although the writing part isn’t as glamorous as the life of a Frisbee star, it pays the bills and makes some people happy. Eventually, my ability to throw a Frisbee will improve, and I will have a good amount of money in the bank to support me in my quest. That’s when I make my move and get noticed on the world scene. The same thing will happen with Nova Scotia’s vinifera wines. I guarantee it. Regions like Nova Scotia, Michigan and New York can grow quality vinifera grapes, they just need to select the right ones and use them appropriately according to their climate. The sparkling wines being made from vinifera in Nova Scotia are exceptional, and, I am sure, soon will be some of the best made in North America. The Rieslings (and Pinot Noir!) in New York can be world-class. So what if these regions grow a lot of hybrids? If it supports the local industry and palates of local wine drinkers while giving the wineries more time and money to play with vinifera grapes, I am fine with it. And here I was thinking that the automakers and environment are the only ones benefitting from hybrids. So, if you are fortunate enough to come and visit us in Nova Scotia, make sure you bring your palate and an open mind, and yes, we check for both at the border. While here, visit one of our 11 wineries within an hour’s drive of our beautiful capital city, Halifax and treat yourself to Benjamin Bridge’s Méthode Classique sparkling wines or their Moscato-esque Nova 7, Gaspereau Vineyard’s Riesling, L’Acadie Vineyards’ Prestige Brut and Domaine de Grand Pré’s Icewines. However, don’t stop there. Come for the whole taste of Nova Scotia. Jonathan Wilson graduated from the Canadian Association of Professional Sommeliers in 2009 and was the recipient of the Kent Clarke Award for top graduating student. He possesses a Level 3 Advanced Certificate in Wines & Spirits from the Wine and Spirits Education Trust in London, and is currently working on his Level 4 Diploma in hopes of someday becoming a Master of Wine. He also possesses a Bachelor of Science in Biology from Dalhousie University in Halifax, Nova Scotia. Jonathan lives to write, speak and teach about wine as can be witnessed through his work with his business, Labeled Wine Consulting. He is also the resident sommelier at Nectar Social House in Dartmouth, Nova Scotia. Great wine, social media, and branding are not just strategies he utilizes in his business, they are his passions. Pingback: Wine Wines @ everything! » Blog Archive » Nova Scotia Hybrids – Palate Pres() Pingback: Nova Scotia Hybrids : PALATE PRESS | Proctor() Pingback: Tweets that mention Nova Scotia Hybrids : PALATE PRESS -- Topsy.com() Pingback: Yes, Nova Scotia makes some awesome wine. Who knew?! | BoozeNews() http://frogspad.ca Craig Pinhey An interesting piece, Jonathan. My only beef with it is that it makes the assumption that there should be a difference in quality between different grape species. I don’t think there is a scientific case for that. You should talk to Paul Troop, a grape grower on Salt Spring Island. He never uses the term hybrid. All grapes are mutations, crosses, etc. evolved (or created) from other grapes. Vinifera grapes are not more pure or genetically superior. Bad Pinot Noir is as bad as bad Foch, and sometimes worse. If you taste a good NS L’Acadie, NY Muscat or Millot, there is nothing that tips them off as being a different species from Pinot Grigio, Muscat Ottonel or Merlot. Look at L’Acadie sparklers, incl. the Foch rose. No one could guess these were from “inferior” species. I try not to use vinifera or hybrid in writing or speaking anymore. Jonathan Wilson Hey Craig, great points. Although, I still think there should be a differentiation because we are talking about different species, the same way I think we should know when someone is using a different grape clone, cross, etc. I use the term hybrid because that is the scientific term the for species and how it was created. I think where the differentiation between the two species comes in for me is not in the “bad” wines, but in the “good” ones. Maybe it’s just my personal taste preference, but even when blind tasting, I don’t seem to like the “good” Fochs, Bacos, etc. and I know I’m not alone. The whites I love, but it is more so the reds, and of course there are exceptions. Quality winemakers using quality techniques in quality areas find a way to make great wine regardless of the grape. Let me ask you this: Would the hybrid varietals like L’Acadie Blanc exist if they were not created by someone in a “lab”? To me, that doesn’t seem as pure as say, Pinot Noir. Sure, the Pinot we know today has mutated more times than we can count, but it is still genetically traceable as the same unadulterated grape put on this earth many, many years ago. Pingback: Nova Scotia Hybrids » labeled.ca – opening bottles and minds() http://frogspad.ca Craig Pinhey I don’t know the answer to that question. We need a grape breeder to do that. But I think that if the grapes exist in the same vineyard area then the opportunity for spontaneous crosses (I prefer the term cross – forget hybrid, they are all crosses, just that some are inter-species) is there (Cab Sauv came from Franc and Sauv Blanc). I’m not a biologist, but I wonder of the parallel is looking at other foods we eat. Is the difference between Baco Noir and Cabernet Sauvignon (both are grapes) similar to the difference between two types of cows, or is it more like comparing a pig to a cow. I think the former. It depends on the grapes in the cross, too. I don’t compare labrusca based crosses to the Minnestoa varieties. As for vinifera being the superior species, well, I guess it is in the areas where they are prevalent, which is mainly climate related. Cab Sauv is DEFINITELY not superior to Baco in Ontario, in my opinion, in all but the most exceptional years. So what about Gamay? It’s superior to Cab Sauv in Ontario too, most years, but is it better than Baco? I’m not sure on that. I’ve also had amurensis reds in the US (Michigan, New York) that blow away many “superior” grape wines. In blind tastings, I can’t believe you don’t like a good Baco like Reserve Henry of P. Has to be double blind (you don’t even know it is there). I think that the red blends being made in NS, using oak treatment, and letting them age a bit (using some older vintage wine, maybe, in the blend) are resulting in better balanced reds. I think much of the problem with greenness, acid and weediness in the past was due to unripe Foch. The really good wines don’t need sugar to balance acid. They are already balanced. Have you ever had a properly aged Jost Foch? No way you’d say it had any of the characterisitcs people often attribute to that grape. http://winecase.ca Remy Charest Craig, you make a good point about the fact that hybrids in a proper place can make better wines that vinifera in the wrong one – I’m sure Foch in Quebec produces better stuff than sangiovese would. However, I haven’t seen one hybrid wine that reached as high as the best vinifera yet, and because of certain characters that are different in hybrids, I remain skeptical that you could really get a hybrid grand cru somewhere. This is not to invalidate the fact that I’ve tasted very pleasant, even very solid wines made from hybrids, and that I think they have a justifiable place in the wine world and on the market. But I have yet to have one – in the reds, in particular – that would really blow me away. The difference between vinifera and French-American/labrusca crossings is greater than crosses between vinifera. If crossing between viniferas are types of cows, than hybrids are like a crossing between a cow and a buffalo – maybe viable and truly interesting in many respects, but really not just another cross. http://frogspad.ca Craig Pinhey I have had some fantastic aged Foch from Jost that would shock many wine experts in a true blind judging. I don’t think most people do TRUE blind judging, mixing in these crosses with vinifera. I mean when tasters have no idea they are even in the flight. I have rarely done it myself. When you know it’s there, it changes how you taste. I think there are some really bizarre, spicy, odd, grapey, vegetal tasting VINIFERA grapes in Italy, Portugal and other old world regions that have a lot in common with some of our local favourites. Quite often the experts are delighted by these odd, quirky finds. But if you had told them up front: “Try this hybrid!” then they would have already hated it before taking a sniff. I also think that more time is needed before we truly judge these grapes and how they taste on our terroir. How long has France been making Cab and Pinot? http://www,carone.ca anthony Hello Craig, Remy. I thought I would add a few comments I hear from all the time from the growers in this country. First of all, regardless of pedigree, if a vine is not suited correctly to the area, it will not produce outstanding wines. It really has nothing to do with hybrid versus purity. It is, however, entirely based on sustainability. Show me a hybrid grower, and I will show you a starving farmer. Sure, maybe a few are making money, but the majority cannot cross the chasm growing and marketing a wine from Marechal Foch! (not to pick on Foch). the fundemental problem hybrid growers have is trying to connect with an audience (and this includes wine writers, critics, sommeliers, connaiseurs) that is well rounded in European varieties. And not European varieties from Georgia, Sarajevo, Poland, Austria, Greece, Germany, etc..but Italy and France. Try entering a foch in an international wine competition against a Burgundy PN and see what happens to your reputation or credibilty. The farmers already know that certain hybrids outperform certain vinifera, there is no need for further convincing there. It is with the Rest of the world. Sure you can come up with clever names (like BIN33) to market and sell your wines, but trying selling a varietal Foch or Sabrevois in Ontario or Quebec. There are other reasons that I won’t get into right now why we want to grow vinifera instead of hybrids, but I think the main issue is marketability! I am sure Jost would love to export his wines to Europe, maybe even France. But I think the law prohibits any import of hybrid wines into those countries unless the variety is on their approved list. Last time I checked, it was not! A grape is just a grape. At the end of the day, it is really up to marketing, sales, and general population trends that make it or break it for the winery. Me-too wineries or what I like to call the French knock-offs, export everything including the grape to a new country and replicate those wines. We have several in Ontario and B.C. What is unique http://www,carone.ca anthony got cut off… what is unique here is that the flow of wine is completely open in Canada’s direction but trickles to a near stop the other. Smaller cottage wineries are not effected, and they have the option to produce wines from an endless selection of grapes, be it vinifera, semi-noble or the super hardies. However, mid size wineries requiring some form of distribution cannot afford this luxury. They must compete at the international level with THEIR rules! That means you better start to figure out how to ripen Sangiovese in 160 frost free days and with maybe 1600 GDD’s.! the natural progression is apparent. Ontario went through this (major rip-out program sponsored by the governemamam), so did B.C. New York’s finger lakes, Virginia, Maryland, Long Island, etc… there are three stages in the progression of a new AVA: those are 1:WE did it Wrong 2:WE compromise, and 3:WE did it RIGHT. At this stage, it easy to see where some of the progressive QC wineries are in the process. http://frogspad.ca Craig Pinhey Interesting stuff… But who cares about selling to Europe? If Canadians bought a reasonable amount of our own wine, all the wineries would be out by mid January! As for selling Foch, Baco etc, Quail’s Gate OVF is arguably their best wine, and Henry of Pelham sells Baco out the ying yang in Niagara. The key word you said was MARKETING. No one is properly marketing these lesser known grapes. Well, maybe Benjamin Bridge…they had people going nuts over a New York Muscat, and then a red non-vinifera cross blend, and now their L’Acadie. Smart. Brand properly, educate, and market. If the wine is good, and you market smartly, graperacism can be eliminated. Jonathan Wilson Craig, I completely agree with the marketing part. Benjamin Bridge has a marketing director, and it shows. It will be interesting to see trends once this ridiculous cross-border shipping law gets vanquished and wine lovers from across Canada can purchase the wines they want from Nova Scotia, Ontario, Quebec and BC. Bart Good discussion! We enccounter the same problems with these new crossings in the Netherlands and Belgium. In addition to better marketing (please don’t call the new crossings ‘hybrids’, it’s like calling them ‘radioactive’), there are two other hurdles to take: 1) most winemakers have less experience with these grapes than with the older varieties. It will take time to get to know these crossings and how to deal with them in less good years. And those winemakers are often new to the winemaking business and can not fall back on years of experience in the family, like they can in France, Spain or Italy. 2) most wine drinkers (including the professionals) have grown up with the main traditional grapes (Cab.Sauv., Merlot, Chardonnay and maybe one or two others). These grapes are there reference. Anything deviating from their taste is considered as less good. This is already true for unknown vinifera varieties like eg. Kékfrankos or Furmint. Educating wine drinkers and convincing them to taste and buy something new will be a though job. I know good wines can be made from the new crossings, i will keep telling the rest of the world. http://www.carone.ca anthony Who cares about selling to Europe? Probably every single member on the VQA committee in BC and Ontario. But lets look at this from an economic standpoint: So we allow Canadian wineries to sell their products locally because they aren’t good enough for the European palate? That seems fine initially right? Canada has a population of about 35 million and about 1000 or so wineries; who can easily compete against the imports adn there is room to navigate. But what happens when that number of 1000 wineries grows to 5000 or even 10,000 and the market size remains relatively flat;the same? Erosion, saturation and a great deal of M&A happen. And it gets real ugly! So the future of Canadian wineries is what exactly if we don’t care about opening up our wines to international trade and removing trade barriers in Europe? I know of a good way to resolve this issue but I am sure WTO, GATT and maybe even a few other trade agreements would be set on fire! (Germany was subjected to this same trade discrimination, got pissed off and set WWII in motion). http://www.carone.ca anthony Craig: If you think it is possible to have even one hybrid wine gain a national following, then by all means prove me wrong. GO out there, setup a highly publicized tasting against the viniferas and tell the whole world about it! I think it is about time that our very own wine media folks finally started to evaluate the semi-noble and super hardy wines equally against the viniferas produced in Canada or from France or Italy. “L’acadie Blanc wine from Caribou winery in Quebec beats out Premier Grand Cru Chablis Chardonnay in blind tasting….” Now that would make headlines around the globe…. http://www.carone.ca anthony Norton says! The only hybrid grape successfully marketed in North America http://www.nortonsays.com/ But, the demographics are very different to Canada. The U.S. produces a great deal of local wine. There is a higher sense of buy local and the distribution of wine is not monopolized by government who have very lucrative trade agreements with Europe. All these obstacles to overcome…none of which are in the growers control. Paul Troop OK, I’ll throw in my two cents. First, lets call hybrids what they are – interspecific crosses. The history of vinifera is long and we are only recently becoming aware of the genetic makeup of some of those vines. Is it not assumed that much of the grapevine material came into the Western European region from a more Eastern or Persian origin, which if true, would almost certainly mean that vinifera is based in interspecific crosses from that region? It would make sense that over hundreds or thousands of years, selections of natural crosses (field seedlings) and intentional natural breeding would have taken place in particular regions – selections that would be best suited to the growing conditions of a given place. Most, if not all of the new interspecific crosses are not made in the lab. They are bred using natural means. There are many people in the world working in this field, some private, some corporate and some academic. The main reasons for crossing species and varieties are to develop grapes with cold hardiness and/or disease resistance. On the note of disease resistance, it is my opinion that to grow vinifera is at least somewhat environmentally irresponsible in most circumstances. The new crosses are eliminating 90+% of the sprays required to grow vinifera. That’s not just the spray, it’s also the diesel for the tractors, labour, soil compaction likely a large reduction in health concerns for the workers. I can say with some certainty that the so-called Hybrids have come a long ways. There are now a good number of varieties that are much better than the early French/American crosses, making wines different from, but as good as the sacred Vinifera. http://frogspad.ca Craig Pinhey Nice to hear form you Paul. BTW Anthony, maybe you don’t read Wine Access (wish you would subscribe, it helps pay my bills as I am their only Atlantic writer) but L’Acadie Vineyards Brut (100% L’Acadie Blanc) Prestige 2007 was the highest scoring sparkling wine this year in BLIND judgings against a large array of many of the nation’s best bubblies. The judges were mostly west coast palates. So there you go. The example is already right in front of your nose. =8) Historically, a Nova Scotia VIdal icewine won the Best Wine in Canada, and New York Muscat Icewine from Grand Pre and Jost have been Gold Medal winners in National competitions, in blind judgings against many of BC and Ontario’s best…. http://www.carone.ca anthony Craig: I did not know! I obviously need to be subscribed to Wine Access. So how do we, host a wine tasting like this at a much higher level/calibre so the whole world can be an audience? Can we organize an international wine judging that includes all Canadian wines against the Europeans’ without discriminating the wine classes based on grape pedigree? For example: Blind tasting grand crus bubbly against Canada’s best sparkling regardless of the grape type or vinification method (champenois versus charmant versus russian)? Obviously new wine classes would have to be created. Jonathan Wilson Vidal and L’Acadie Blanc have won medals in national competitions, but what about the reds from Nova Scotia? Has a red hybrid (yes, I call them that) won anything in a national competition besides best hybrid? I feel the whites are far more approachable to a palate trained on vinifera. http://frogspad.ca Craig Pinhey 1st : I don’t believe Canadian wineries have aspirations to sell internationally except icewine. They enter international comps to get acclaim to sell wine here. it would be folly otherwise. Maybe a few bottles here and there, but surely they don’t expect Canada to be a big wine exporter. Niche is all we can be. 2nd: Almost all of our vineyard land suitable for vinifera and other tender varieties is planted, right? So it is a moot point. We won’t have 5000 wineries making vinifera, and I doubt non-vinifera either. I think the growth will slow. 3rd: I don’t care much what international panels think about our wines, to be truthful, particularly Wine Snobtator… I WANT CANADIANS TO DRINK MAINLY OUR OWN WINES! (and read Canadian wine magazines that are relevant to our culture, palates and food) If we can achieve that, THEN we have a really functional wine industry. 4th: It’s true that NS reds are tougher, but I’ve seen a big change in that area recently. More knowledgeable growers and winemakers = better wines. The whites are EASY! (ha ha). I think one big problem is we don’t age our best reds enough before drinking. Cool climate acid needs time! http://www.YorkWines.org Gary Cox I find it interesting that in recent years 19th century Native American chance hybrid varieties, competing with Vinifera and French hybrids (and some 20th century American hybrids) have won best rosé of the show in recent large international competitions: Goose Watch (Finger Lakes, NY) Isabella, and Torrey Ridge (Finger Lakes, NY) Catawba. And a deliberate 1870 Native American hybrid tied for best white wine of the show, besting virtually all the best-of-class, gold medal-winning Chardonnays, Rieslings, Pinot Grigios, Sauvignon Blancs, etc. entered from North America and abroad. These were at 2010 and other recent instances of the Long Beach Grand Cru. Interesting! http://70percentoffblue.blogspot.com/ bluehost coupons 2014 If you’re using a hard time determining just how much your monthly obligations of financing are getting to be together with your basic pen and paper, maybe it is time to have somewhat more technologically advanced bluehost coupons 2014 graduated repayment plan: this option may also permit that you stretch your instalments on the longer amount of 12 in order to three decades.