By now you’re heard the news, Alcohol May Help Fight Weight Gain In Women! You don’t have to take Wine Spectator’s word for it, either. You can also read about it in Health News, Digital Journal, NPR, the Vancouver Sun, Yahoo, the Sacramento Bee, even The Times of India. Any news that promises weight loss is gulped down here in America even faster than we bolt our super-sized Big Mac, fries, and shake combos. But is there anything to it? Let’s look behind the curtain, shall we?

The study was published by Archives of Internal Medicine this week. It is entitled “Alcohol Consumption, Weight Gain, and Risk of Becoming Overweight in Middle-aged and Older Women.” Vol. 170, No. 5, March 8, 2010, p. 453-461.

The study did not set out to investigate women, wine, and weight. Rather, it was a randomized clinical trial evaluating the effects of low-dose aspirin and vitamin E in the primary prevention of cardiovascular disease and cancer. The findings that have everybody so excited were actually part of the baseline questionnaire. Adjustments were made first for age, then for race, baseline BMI, randomized treatment, nonalcohol energy intake, physical activity level, smoking habits, postmenopausal status, postmenopausal hormone use, multivitamin use, history of hyperchloesterolemia and hypertension, and dietary factors.  They did not adjust for income.

One rather interesting find is that, compared with non-drinkers, women who consumed more alcohol were more likely to be white smokers. Women who consumed moderate alcohol also had the highest levels of physical activity.

So what were the results that have everybody so excited? What we are hearing is that “Women of a normal weight who consume alcohol in moderation appear to gain less weight over time than nondrinkers.” Wine Spectator.

Curiously, these results seem gender-specific. The study mentions that its results are consistent with other studies that all had similar findings, specific to women, while alcohol consumption in men lead to weight gain.

Alcohol consumption was divided into different tiers, 0-5 grams per day (g/d), 5-15 g/d, 15-30 g/d, and over 30 g/d. They also noted consumption of more than 40 g/d, but did not include much information at that level in the study.

The key language in the study that has everybody buzzing is:

Compared with nondrinkers, women who consumed more than 0 to less than 5, 5 to less than 15, 15 to less than 30, and 30 g/d or more of alcohol had age-adjusted RRs (relative risks) of 0.96, 0.84, 0.73, and 0.78, respectively, for becoming overweight or obese. The risk of becoming overweight or obese was not further reduced for women consuming 40 g/d or more of alcohol (age-adjusted RR, 0.90 [95% CI, 0.71-1.13]). These RRs changed little after multivariate adjustment. An inverse association between alcohol intake and risk of becoming overweight or obese was noted for all 4 types of alcoholic beverages, with the strongest association found for red wine and a weak yet significant association for white wine after multivariate adjustment.

Let’s break that down a bit. The baseline for the study was the group of nondrinkers. They get a “relative risk” value of 1. “Relative risk” measures the possibility of becoming obese, not as an absolute, but compared to others. A person with a relative risk of 0.5 is half as likely to become obese as a person with an RR of 1. In the study, the RR went down, so the likelihood of become obese went down, as alcohol intake went up. A person who drank 0-5 grams of alcohol per day was 4% less likely to become obese than a non-drinker, while a person who drank 15-30 g/d was only 73% as likely to become obese. Above 30 g/d, the number ticked up slightly, to 78%. (Above 40 g/d the numbers were statistically identical to 30-40 g/d.)

The end of the paragraph notes that the strongest association was for red wine. This is the only sentence in the article that distinguishes one type of alcohol from the other, which is interesting, because the language seems to indicate that only the correlation to red wine has strong statistical significance, white wine a weak but significant association, leaving one to wonder whether there is any statistical significance at all for beer and hard liquor. “Significance,” here, does not mean importance, but statistical significance, meaning a result that is unlikely to have occurred by chance.

This is the latest in a line of studies that showed an inverse relationship between alcohol intake and obesity in women. In studies that looked at both genders the results were different for men. Across the board, in studies from the United States to Norway to China, obesity in men was in a direct relationship, rather than an inverse relationship, to alcohol intake. That was explained by findings that men tend to add alcohol to their daily dietary intake, while women substitute alcohol for other food without increasing their dietary intake. Women also seem to metabolize alcohol differently. Together, that means alcohol intake results in a gain of potential energy intake for men but a loss for women.

So have we found it, the magic elixir, the juice that will keep America’s women lithe and young forever?

Perhaps not.

Do you remember when I mentioned that the study did not adjust for income? That part is important. There is a well-recognized inverse relationship between income and obesity in women in America.

Let’s start with The New England Journal of Medicine, in “Obesity and Socioeconomc Status — A Complex Relation.” NEJM, Volume 329:1036-1037, September 30, 1993, Number 14. The abstract for this editorial states:

One of the most striking facts about obesity is the powerful inverse relation between obesity and socioeconomic status in the developed world, especially among women. What is responsible for this association? There are at least three possibilities: obesity influences socioeconomic status, socioeconomic status influences obesity, or a common factor or factors influence both obesity and socioeconomic status. There is evidence to support each of these possibilities, and limits to the evidence for each.

The editorial observed that multiple studies demonstrated the link between socioeconomic status and obesity, but the cause was more complex, also including heredity and other factors. While socioeconomic status had a clear effect on obesity, obesity also had an effect on socioeconomic status, as the obese suffered a social disability, and loss of income, for their weight. The purpose of the editorial was to encourage doctors to treat their patients without prejudice, to address the symptoms without adding to the list of “horror stories” about treatment by insensitive physicians.

We can see a more detailed, and more modern, study in Age, Socioeconomic Status, and Obesity Growth, Baum and Ruhm. They, too, found that “adult body weight and obesity are inversely related to social and economic advantage.” Id. It is actually quite complex, not a simple straight line money/weight analysis, in part because obesity itself generates a “weight penalty,” reduced wages for increased weight. The conclusion, though, is pretty straight-forward, “excess body weight is inversely related to socioeconomic status at all observed points of the lifecycle and these disparities increase with age.” In other words, the more money you have, the less likely you are to be obese.

Can we take a look at wine consumers, now? I will use, as a proxy, combined demographic data from more than forty wine websites, collected among The Palate Press Advertising Network‘s network of more than 70 different wine websites. What do we find? First, we find that wine readers, and presumably wine drinkers, are more affluent and more educated than average, and have fewer children in the household. The “Index” on the graph is a comparison the internet average. An index of 100 would mean the measure is identical to the internet average, while an index of 133 would mean 33% above the internet average. These measures come from Quantcast.

Remember, the study everybody is talking about did NOT adjust for education or income.

So what do we conclude from the study? Perhaps something significant, that red wine helps women keep weight off. But it is more likely we are merely rediscovered something we already knew, that the poorer and less educated you are in America, the less likely you are to be healthy.

But that does not make as interesting a headline.

About The Author

David Honig
  • Pingback: Wine, Women, and Weight : PALATE PRESS Economic Finance news

  • Pingback: uberVU - social comments

  • Pingback: What Can You Do To Prevent Sweating

  • Keith Marton

    In fact, this study DID account for education and socioeconomic status. The study only looked at healthy women working as health professionals (mostly nurses), so–for the most part–they have similar levels of education and similar income levels.
    This makes the findings even more robust, but not necessarily generalizable to other populations.

  • Pingback: Weight Loss Diet | Lose Weight » Blog Archive » Is a well balanced diet a cookie in each hand?

  • http://www.hairlosstreatmentlab.com Alexis Martin

    more people are becoming obese these days because of too much junk food and too much sugar in snacks and fast foods. |

  • http://www.gelfuel.info Madison Davis

    Hypertension is very common among old men and women these days.”–

  • http://www.usbtoserial.net Henry Anderson

    hypertension is a common disease among the older age men and women.“’

  • http://www.lettertray.net Letter Tray :

    due to the busy schedules from work, most people would just prefer to eat on fastfoods :

  • Pingback: Wine – where do you start? » Blog Archive » Wine, Women & the Blues

  • http://www.morenovalleywaterdamage.com water damage moreno valley

    Your nice blog is actually worth a read if anyone results in it. Im lucky i did because now Ive got a complete new view of this kind of. I didnt realise which the issue was so important because of this universal. You definitely place it in perspective for me, thanks for the fantatic details.

  • http://healthy-usa.com cardio

    I’ve been searching in google for some new ideas and accidentally found your palatepress.com site. Thanks for sharing this information. I find it very informative as I have been studying a lot lately on practical matters such as you talk about..

  • http://palatepress.com/2010/03/wine/wine-women-and-weight/?& Addison

    That is Amazing! Thank you.

  • http://palatepress.com/2010/03/wine/wine-women-and-weight/?& Aaron

    This site rocks !. I continually come across new stuff & distinct listed here. Appreciation for that data.

  • http://evitaperfumes.typepad.com/ rebecca minkoff beloved

    It really is actually a nice and very helpful piece of details. I am happy which you shared this handy info along with us. Make sure you keep informed similar to this. Many thanks for sharing.

  • http://Inteens.net/forum/member.php?21944-nick5544 impotence

    If you would like to cure impotence you do not require drugs, you are able to obtain a hard erection by getting the
    enclosed herbal remedies and not just do they get you a
    tougher hard-on, these herbal remedies will do
    something which drugs simply cannot do and that’s improve your libido in the same time – lets take a look at how they function.

    Herbal remedies about the other hand, improve your libido so you benefit from the complete sexual encounter.

    Numerous males get frustrated when they consider drugs because there is no increase in sexual intercourse generate plus they require manual stimulation of the penis to get difficult.

    Nitric oxide performs the vital function of opening up the blood vessels which lead to the penis, so they are wide enough to take the increased quantity of blood in, to stiffen the penis.

    Firstly to obtain a difficult erection, you have to have higher amounts of nitric oxide produced in the body and also the reason for this is easy – no erection can take place if amounts are as well low.

    Testosterone is the crucial male sexual intercourse hormone and is required for sex generate and sexual stamina and the good news is – Horny Goat Weed and Cnidium (which we have already pointed out) will give levels a boost.

    You ought to also however consider Tribulus, because not just is it the best testosterone boosting herb, it also contains a unique blend of nutrients which increase sexual intercourse generate and increase intensity and pleasure from orgasm.

    If you want to cure impotence quickly and naturally, you are able to get all of the above herbs within the best natural hard-on supplements and they will get you a harder hard-on and also increase your sexual intercourse generate in the exact same time – try them and you’ll be glad you did.

    he cause herbal remedies are a much better alternative to man
    made medicines is – they have no harmful side affects and simply because they increase sexual intercourse generate which can be
    something man created drugs simply can’t do, lets consider a take a look at how the herbs work.

    If you want to obtain an hard-on, you have to increase your levels of nitric oxide. Nitric oxide may be the key organic chemical which permits an erection to arrive to fruition – no erection can take place without it.

    Prescription drugs do this but you do not need them, the herbal remedies Horny Goat Weed, ginseng and Cnidium, will do this too and even better news is – they do it safely and naturally.

    Herbal remedies could possibly get you a hard hard-on and treat impotence normally – but they can also increase your libido which is essential, for that complete all round sexual experience.

    Numerous men are left frustrated by guy made medicines simply because, they get them hard but they often require manual stimulation and this leads to an incomplete sexual encounter.

    The good news is – herbal remedies could possibly get you hard, without manual stimulation plus they do this in a number of methods that are outlined below.

    Testosterone is required for sexual stamina andlibido and Horny Goat Weed and Ginseng (which we have already mentioned) improve amounts but you ought to also take another couple of herbal remedies which are Tribulus and Tonkgat Ali.

    Last bit not least, the mind also plays a crucial role in terms of sexual wellness and if you are stressed, anxious worried or depressed, you won’t have the ability to focus on sexual
    intercourse.

    You can take herbal remedies that will enhance your mood and two great ones are –
    Maca and Ginkgo Biloba which both improve mood and give the body an energy boost at the exact same time.

    Within the best organic libido pills and not just will they treat impotence and provide you with a hard erection, they may also improve
    sex drive and overall levels of wellness at the exact same time.

    mental impotence is nearly guaranteed to impact men a minimum of once within their
    life. Prior to people didn’t see this as an actual issue, they merely chalked it as much as old age.

    But in today’s society this really is really
    treated being a problem. There are numerous ways for
    individuals to recover from mental impotence.

    Through recent many years psychological treatments have
    come a long way via long arduous research and practice. Now that
    we know both the reasons for the difficulties and the way to alleviate them, it’s imperative that you simply take advantage of them.

    A large problem that can trigger mental impotence is either associated to a past concern or it’s temporary.
    It can truly be a cycle of fear.

    A single issue can result in the fear of re-occurrence can create anxiety that will cause the initial problem
    just as we feared. Even tough this kind of mental impotence is fairly stream lined.

    You ought to never be ashamed of this problem, and numerous males close to the world are afflicted by it each single day.
    This is the result of the emotions effecting you physically.

    An excellent method to solve this issue is to become relaxed prior to you turn out to be physical.
    Music and atmosphere is a great way to get